Why So Many Vacation Rentals Look the Same (And Why That's a Problem)

There's no shortage of vacation rentals these days. But there is a shortage of ones that actually stand out and deliver what guests actually want.
Spend ten minutes browsing Airbnb in just about any popular vacation destination, and you'll probably start noticing a pattern.
Barebones bedrooms with a bed, a couple of pillows, and not much else. Living rooms with a random assortment of furniture that doesn't quite fit together. A dining table that seats 4 people in a property advertised for 8. Maybe a generic piece of wall art, a couple of artificial plants, and the obligatory "Lake Life" sign.
And somehow, that's supposed to be a vacation experience worth paying hundreds of dollars a night for.
Don't get me wrong, not every vacation rental needs to be luxurious or over-the-top; there's absolutely a place for simple, affordable accommodations.
But there's a difference between a thoughtfully designed, modest vacation rental and a property that looks like someone furnished it in a weekend with whatever they could find.
And that difference matters more than a lot of investors realize.
Furnishing a Property Isn't the Same as Designing One
I originally founded WildeWoods Design because I saw a huge opportunity in the vacation rental market, and I saw that hosts needed help.
Guests are paying to enjoy time away from home... and they can get a generic, bland experience at the nearest hotel. So ideally, their vacation rental accommodations should offer an enhanced, cozy, homey experience rather than simply somewhere to sleep.
And yet, the majority of Airbnbs are still offering sterile and downright unhospitable accommodations, which guests are only booking during peak season weekends when demand outpaces supply, but are sitting empty much of the year.
I don't think a vacation rental needs to be extravagant, but a comfortable bed, proper nightstands, good reading lights, somewhere to put a suitcase, and a little atmosphere go a long way in becoming a first choice and an enjoyable place to spend time all year long.
That's not luxury. That's good hospitality.

Have You Ever Tried Staying in One of These Places?
Here's something I wish more vacation rental owners would do before listing their properties:
Spend a few days actually living in the space.
Not just walking through to make sure everything looks presentable. I mean cook dinner, watch a movie, take a shower, unpack your suitcase, and sleep in the bed. You might discover a few things!
Like the fact that there's nowhere to put your phone or glass of water beside the bed because you didn't provide nightstands. Or that you have to rummage through your overnight bag on the floor because there's no dresser, luggage rack, or bench. Or that the ceiling fan rattles. Maybe your house is set up to sleep 10, yet your living room only seats 4 comfortably. Or the lighting is so harsh that nobody wants to spend an evening relaxing there.
These aren't necessarily expensive problems to solve. They're problems that arise when someone approaches furnishing a property as a checklist rather than thinking through how people will actually use it.
And as someone who's been involved in operating a vacation rental for years, I can tell you that the little conveniences matter.
Guests might not consciously notice every thoughtful detail, but they absolutely notice when something they need isn't there. A well-designed vacation rental should anticipate those needs before guests ever arrive.

Your Photos Need to Sell the Experience. Your Property Needs to Deliver It.
Of course the visuals are critically important; vacation rentals are marketed and booked through photographs. When someone is scrolling through dozens of listings, you have a very short opportunity to catch their attention. And no, a token particle board plaque that says "Welcome to the Lake" doesn't exactly cut it.
Don't worry if your property doesn't have dramatic architecture or magical mountain views; with the right blend of character, cohesion, and thoughtful details you'll still have guests booking your rental over the many other options out there.
Maybe it's a beautifully layered cottage with vintage furnishings. A cozy cabin with warm lighting and inviting textures. Or a bright, airy lake house that makes you immediately picture yourself spending a summer weekend there. The point is to create an atmosphere that photographs well and your ideal guests can see themselves wanting to spend time in; one that will become an important part of their travel experience.
And while the photographs need to capture someone's imagination, the actual property has to live up to those expectations. Which brings me to one of my favorite (and admittedly less glamorous) aspects of vacation rental design...
'Pretty' Is Only Half the Battle
A lot of things that look fantastic in a magazine or on Pinterest aren't necessarily practical for a busy rental property.
Take those big, furry decorative pillows. They might photograph beautifully, but how easily can they be thoroughly cleaned between guests?
What about that delicate rug under the dining table? How's that going to hold up when someone spills an entire glass of red wine?
When you're designing for paying guests, you have to think beyond the initial installation.
How will materials wear? Can they be properly cleaned? How easily can furnishings be repaired or replaced? Will the property still look inviting after dozens of different guests have spent time there?
I spend a lot of time thinking about durability, maintenance, cleaning, and how furnishings will perform over time. Because nobody wants a vacation rental that looks beautiful for its first photo shoot and tired six months later. And nobody wants to spend their rental income constantly replacing things that weren't suited to the environment in the first place.
Good Design Doesn't Necessarily Mean Spending More Money
Now, before this starts sounding like an argument for investors to throw unlimited amounts of money at their properties, let me clarify something. I'm a big believer in working within realistic budgets.
I've furnished properties using secondhand finds, vintage pieces, Facebook Marketplace purchases, and creative solutions to stretch a client's dollars. In fact, sometimes those pieces are what give a property its personality.
The difference is in how they're selected and used. There's nothing wrong with a $150 secondhand dresser if it's attractive, functional, and makes sense in the room.
There is something wrong with spending $150 on a dresser simply because it's cheap, without considering whether it fits, functions, or belongs there.
The same applies to the overall project budget. I'd much rather see an investor create a really great, thoughtfully designed midrange property than attempt to create something that attempts to "look luxury" on an unrealistic budget and end up cutting corners everywhere.
It's not about spending the most. It's about making the money you do spend count.
Sometimes that means investing in a great mattress or a sofa that actually accommodates your guests. Sometimes it means saving money on a thrifted dining table so you can afford better lighting or more durable materials elsewhere.
Good design is about making those decisions strategically rather than treating every item as an isolated purchase.
And Then There's the Airbnb Algorithm...
Spend any time in vacation rental owner groups, and you'll see plenty of conversations about slow bookings. Is Airbnb changing its algorithm? Is the market oversaturated? Why is nobody booking? Is everyone else having a slow season?
They're fair questions. And to be clear, a property's performance depends on all sorts of factors: location, market demand, competition, pricing, amenities, seasonality, and plenty of things outside an owner's control.
But I think there's another question that doesn't get asked nearly enough:
Have you actually created a property that gives guests a compelling reason to choose it?
If your listing looks like dozens of others in the same market, your furniture is uninspiring, your photos are unremarkable, and your amenities don't reflect what your target guests want, you've made it that much harder to stand out.
Great design can't fix every problem with a vacation rental investment. It certainly can't manufacture demand where there isn't any. But thoughtful design and a well-planned guest experience are two important things that owners can control. And they're worth considering before the listing goes live—not just after the bookings disappoint.

Think Like a Hospitality Business, Not Just a Property Owner
At the end of the day, a vacation rental isn't just real estate with furniture in it; it's a hospitality business.
And that means thinking about the people who you want to actually stay there. What drew them to the area? What are they coming to experience? Who are they traveling with? What will make their stay comfortable, convenient, and memorable?
It also means thinking about the operational realities: cleaning, maintenance, durability, replacements, and how the property will hold up over time.
I've spent years approaching vacation rentals from both sides—as a designer and as an active host. This means I'm constantly honing and perfecting the combination between what looks good in listing photos, what creates a comfortable and welcoming ambiance in-person, and what makes the most sense in terms of management, turnovers, and durability so that the initial investment results in maximum ROI over the long-term; avoiding 'death by papercut' syndrome where hosts are persistently dealing with many little issues and minor complaints that can make hosting unenjoyable and expensive.
For some properties it takes a substantial renovation and a healthy design budget. Other times, it means making smarter choices with what's already there. But in either case, it requires more thought than a shopping list and a trip to HomeGoods.
Because the goal shouldn't be to create another Airbnb. It should be to create one worth choosing—and one that lives up to the expectations set by its photos.
A Different Approach to Vacation Rental Design
At WildeWoods Design, I work with vacation rental investors, property owners, and boutique lodging operators throughout Maine and New Hampshire to create spaces that balance personality, practicality, and business goals.
My approach combines creative design with hands-on project leadership and firsthand hospitality experience, with careful attention to both the guest experience and the realities of operating a rental property.
Whether you're starting with an empty property, renovating an existing rental, or trying to make your investment stand out in a competitive market, I'd love to hear what you're working on.



Comments